Menu of Sweetie Pies Amish Bakery & Cafe in Tulsa, Oklahoma, USA

Menu Overview

Sweetie Pies Amish Bakery & Cafe, nestled in Tulsa at 2627 E 11th St A, offers a heartfelt dive into traditional Amish cooking with a warm, inviting atmosphere. This small bakery-cafe hybrid excels at crafting comfort food that feels like a home-cooked meal, served with genuine care and attention to detail.

The menu shines with breakfast specials like the delightfully soft Cinnamon Roll & Coffee combo for just $5.99, and the satisfying Biscuit Sandwich also at $5.99 — perfect for starting your day with authentic flavors. For a more filling option, the Cornbeef with Hash at $11.99 delivers savory richness, while lighter choices like Grits & Toast or Oatmeal & Toast at $4.99 balance simplicity and warmth. The French Toast priced at $7.99 adds a classic sweet touch.

Lunch selections stand out with sandwiches crafted from quality ingredients. The Meatball Sliders with a side ($8.99) are seasoned impressively and come in generous portions. The Bologna Sandwich, a house specialty at $2.99, evokes nostalgic, old-fashioned comfort. For those craving a hearty meal, the Triple Decker Club ($11.99) and Chicken Salad Sandwich ($10.99) offer satisfying choices, balanced with fresh sides.

Kids are well-catered for too, with approachable meals like Turkey, Ham, or PBJ sandwiches, Grilled Cheese, and Macaroni & Cheese, offering value and flavor for younger palates.

What truly sets Sweetie Pies apart is the authenticity of their Amish-inspired dishes, such as the highly praised lasagna with two sides and a roll, where each bite carries a comforting homemade essence. Reviewers frequently highlight the quality of sides—corn, side salad, mashed potatoes—that complement each main dish perfectly. The holiday-style specials, like the Christmas in July turkey dinner with all the fixings, resonate deeply with food lovers looking for that nod to family traditions and seasonal cheer.

The bakery itself is a treasure trove of locally made baked goods — pies, mocha fudge, snickerdoodles, and the standout triple berry jam. These sweets balance the savory menu items with their rich, nostalgic flavors, making Sweetie Pies an excellent choice for celebrations or casual indulgence. Prices remain reasonable, reflecting the genuine quality and care poured into their food.

Customer service here enhances the experience manifold. Friendly and knowledgeable staff, including the owner herself, often engage with diners, offering samples to ensure satisfaction before ordering. This personalized touch, coupled with a cozy yet bustling atmosphere, makes each visit memorable.

Moreover, Sweetie Pies accommodates diverse dietary preferences by offering a gluten-free menu, a thoughtful inclusion that broadens its appeal without sacrificing the beloved Amish comfort style.

In conclusion, Sweetie Pies Amish Bakery & Cafe is more than just a meal — it is a comforting, genuine experience that transports you to a family gathering around a lovingly prepared table. Whether you’re stopping by for their rich breakfast specials, hearty sandwiches, or irresistible baked goods, this Tulsa gem delivers wholesome, flavorful food with warmth and tradition.