Sweetie Pies Amish Bakery Cafe | Charming Comfort Food Baked Goods in Tulsa

Overview

Sweetie Pies Amish Bakery & Cafe, nestled at 2627 E 11th St A in Tulsa, Oklahoma, stands out as a cozy refuge for anyone seeking genuine comfort food and fresh-baked treats. This small but inviting bakery and cafe offers more than just a meal—it delivers a taste of home with every dish and pastry.

The heart of Sweetie Pies lies in its Amish-inspired menu, featuring hearty dishes like tender turkey dinners with all the fixings, savory chicken noodles, and flavorful meatball sliders. Their signature omelets and homemade lasagna show a commitment to wholesome, satisfying flavors crafted with care and quality ingredients. What truly sets Sweetie Pies apart is the evident love and attention baked into every recipe, reflecting a deep respect for tradition and comfort food at its best.

Beyond the main dishes, the bakery itself is a treasure trove of locally made baked goods and groceries. From rich mocha fudge to snickerdoodles and triple berry jam, their sweets complement the savory items perfectly, making it a great stop whether you’re planning a simple lunch or preparing for a gathering. The availability of a gluten-free menu also speaks to their thoughtful approach to dietary needs, broadening their appeal.

The atmosphere at Sweetie Pies is warm and welcoming, albeit modest in size. The space feels homely, with friendly and knowledgeable staff who add to the genuine experience. Reviews highlight not only the quality of food but the thoughtful service, including samples to help guests choose their meals—an uncommon touch that speaks to their customer-first philosophy.

Ideal for locals and visitors alike, Sweetie Pies suits anyone craving subtle, hearty comfort food and wholesome baked goods in a relaxed, inviting setting. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch, a family meal, or some treats to bring home, this cafe offers a true slice of Tulsa’s charm wrapped in Amish-style hospitality.

For those seeking a quietly special dining experience with genuine flavors and hearty portions, Sweetie Pies Amish Bakery & Cafe is a must-visit destination that quietly earns its place as a cherished Tulsa gem.

Amenities & Services

Popular for

Breakfast

Lunch

Solo dining

Offerings

Coffee

Comfort food

Organic dishes

Quick bite

Small plates

Atmosphere

Casual

Cosy

Quiet

What Customers Say

Cyril Philip

Dec 3,2025

4/5

Good - **** Noticed this cafe recently and soon after, I checked their menu. Found some items I liked and thought to have lunch. It is a small bakery cum cafe. I ordered lasagna which comes with two side items and a roll. The portion size of lasagna could have been more but flavor wise, it was good. Liked the corn, side salad and roll too. They have a bakery too which is good.

Rachel Dubrovin

Dec 3,2025

5/5

This is a hidden treasure in Tulsa. You should stop here to grab treats for your next party. They also have a dine in option. They have a variety of baked goods and groceries that are locally made, it’s worth checking out if you haven’t been. Prices aren’t bad at all.

Patricia Higgins

Dec 3,2025

5/5

It doesn't present as clean as the chouteau location but that might be because of the Tulsa location itself..it's clean and I got the meatball sliders...two good portions and cooked perfectly. Seasoning was great as well and the girl lady woman at the counter was friendly and knew her business well. I'm going back for a freezer dinner for older neighbors..good food and pretty reasonable prices. Sweets are good to. Two pies and mocha fudge and snickerdoodles and triple berry jam is the best !

Stacee S

Dec 3,2025

5/5

We went for the first time tonight & actually had the owner as our waitress. She was excellent & offered samples of anything to make sure we like it before we order it. The food was amazing & the salsa was the best I’ve had in a while. You can tell they care about the quality of their product. Definitely go and try them out!

A B (Bewlead)

Dec 3,2025

5/5

Sweetie Pies is such a charming and delicious spot! We stopped in for lunch and tried their Christmas in July special—an incredible turkey dinner with all the fixings and pie. They were also serving Amish-style chicken noodles, and both dishes were full of comforting, homemade flavor. The turkey was tender, the mashed potatoes were creamy, and everything tasted like it came straight from a family holiday table. The chicken noodles were rich, savory, and the kind of comfort food that hits just right. The staff was friendly and welcoming, and even though the space is cozy and can get busy, the atmosphere is warm and inviting. You can tell a lot of love goes into everything they make. It’s rare to find food this heartfelt. Sweetie Pies is a true gem in Tulsa. I’ll definitely be back! **They also have a GF menu

Karime Gil

Dec 3,2025

5/5

I really liked this place. The food was a wonderful surprise, and I could truly feel that homemade flavor that gives this place its special touch. The dishes we ordered were delicious, and I loved the pecan empanadas. The service was excellent—very patient and made us feel right at home. The prices were good, and I’ll definitely be coming back very soon.

Robert Solecki

Dec 3,2025

5/5

We stopped in for lunch, had a grilled ham and cheese on sourdough bread with mac and cheese. It was great.

Sweetie Pies Amish Bakery & Cafe - Restaurants in Tulsa, Oklahoma, USA

Overview

Amenities & Services

What Customers Say

Leave a Review

Location

Opening Hours

More Restaurants in Tulsa, Oklahoma, USA